The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016, is a law in India designed to make it easier to resolve financial troubles for businesses, partnerships, and individuals when they can’t pay their debts. Its main goals are to settle these issues quickly, protect the rights of those owed money (creditors), and encourage new businesses by creating a clear process. Section 52 of the IBC specifically explains what a secured creditor, someone who lent money and holds a guarantee like property or assets, can do when a company is being liquidated (i.e., its assets are sold off to pay debts). This Section gives secured creditors options to either give up their guarantee to share in the liquidation proceeds or recover their money by selling the guaranteed assets themselves.
Unlock new career opportunities with The Legal School’s Certification in Bankruptcy & Insolvency Law: Corporate Restructuring & Debt Resolution, in collaboration with IndusLaw. This six-month program, led by industry experts, equips you with critical skills in insolvency litigation, financial distress management, and corporate rescue strategies. Earn a prestigious certificate and elevate your expertise in a rapidly evolving field!
Detailed Breakdown of Section 52 of IBC
Section 52 is known as Secured creditor in liquidation proceedings and it became effective on December 15, 2016. It outlines the steps a secured creditor must follow during a company’s liquidation. Below is a clear explanation of each part of the section.
Options for Secured Creditors
A secured creditor has two choices during liquidation:
Option A: Give up their security interest (the asset or property guaranteeing their loan) and join the liquidation process. This means they let the liquidator (the person managing the liquidation) sell the assets and share the money according to the rules in Section 53 of IBC.
Option B: Take charge of selling or managing the secured asset themselves to recover the money they’re owed, following the rules in this section.
Informing the Liquidator
If a secured creditor chooses Option B (to handle the secured asset themselves), they must tell the liquidator about their decision. They need to clearly identify which asset they plan to sell or deal with to recover their money.
Verifying the Security Interest
Before the creditor can proceed with selling the asset, the liquidator checks if the security interest is legitimate. The creditor must prove they have a valid claim to the asset, either by:
Showing records from an information utility (a system that stores financial data), or
Providing other proof allowed by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).
Only after this verification can the creditor move forward with selling the asset.
Handling the Secured Asset
The secured creditor can take actions like enforcing, selling, settling, or negotiating deals with the secured asset, as allowed by the relevant laws. The money they recover from these actions is used to pay off the debt owed to them.
Dealing with Resistance
If the company (called the corporate debtor) or someone connected to it (like a manager or related party) tries to stop the creditor from taking or selling the asset, the creditor can ask the Adjudicating Authority (a special court handling insolvency cases) for help. This ensures the creditor can proceed with recovering their money.
Court Orders to Assist
When a creditor asks for help under point 5, the Adjudicating Authority can issue orders to allow the creditor to manage or sell the asset legally, ensuring they can recover their money as per the law.
Handling Extra Money
If the creditor sells the asset and gets more money than what they’re owed, they must:
Report the extra money (called surplus) to the liquidator, and
Give this surplus to the liquidator to be included in the liquidation estate, which is used to pay other creditors.
Paying for Insolvency Costs
If a creditor sells the secured asset themselves, they must use part of the money to cover the costs of the insolvency resolution process (like legal or administrative fees). These costs are deducted from the money they recover, and the creditor must transfer this amount to the liquidator to be part of the liquidation estate.
What Happens if the Money Isn’t Enough
If selling the secured asset doesn’t provide enough money to fully pay off the debt owed to the creditor, the remaining unpaid amount will be handled by the liquidator. The liquidator will pay this according to the priority rules in Section 53(1)(e) of the IBC.
These rules create a clear and fair process for secured creditors, balancing their ability to recover money with the needs of the overall liquidation process. For example, the verification step in point 3 uses trusted records to avoid confusion or disputes about who owns what.
Learn more about Corporate Insolvency Resolution
Practical Implications of Section 52 of IBC
Section 52 gives secured creditors flexibility to either join the liquidation process or handle their secured assets themselves but it comes with clear rules to prevent misuse. For instance:
The requirement to inform the liquidator (point 2) and verify the security interest (point 3) avoids conflicts over assets, as supported by rules like Regulation 37 of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016.
If the company or its associates resist the creditor’s efforts (point 5), the creditor can seek help from the Adjudicating Authority, ensuring they aren’t unfairly blocked.
The rule about returning surplus money (point 7) ensures fairness by sharing extra funds with other creditors.
Deducting insolvency costs (point 8) prioritizes the expenses of running the process, which aligns with Section 53’s payment hierarchy.
Legal experts, as seen on platforms like ibclaw.in, note that Section 52 builds trust among creditors by giving them options, but delays in the liquidation process can sometimes make it harder to recover money quickly.
How Section 52 Relates to Other IBC Sections
Section 52 works hand-in-hand with Section 53, which sets the order for distributing money from liquidation. For example, if a creditor gives up their security (Option A), Section 53(1)(b)(ii) ensures that they are paid along with the workmen’s dues which balances the rights of secured creditors with the needs of others involved in the process.
Summary
Section 52 of IBC 2016 lets the creditors choose between joining the liquidation estate or handling their secured assets themselves, with steps like verification and court assistance to keep things transparent and legal. However, the process can sometimes be slowed by legal complexities or delays in liquidation. For anyone dealing with this section, it’s wise to check detailed legal resources, case laws or IBBI guidelines to understand how it applies in specific situations. Consulting a legal professional can also help navigate any challenges effectively.
Related Posts:
Section 52 of IBC, 2016: FAQs
Q1. What is Section 52 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code?
Section 52 allows a secured creditor to enforce their security interest outside the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) or liquidation, retaining the right to realize their security independently, subject to certain conditions.
Q2. What is Section 53 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code?
Section 53 outlines the priority of distribution of assets during liquidation, ranking claims in a waterfall mechanism, starting with insolvency resolution costs, followed by secured creditors and workmen dues, and so on, down to equity shareholders.
Q3. What is Section 54 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016?
Section 54 provides for the dissolution of a corporate debtor after liquidation, where the liquidator applies to the Adjudicating Authority (NCLT) to dissolve the company once all assets are distributed.
Q4. What is the minimum amount for insolvency?
The minimum default amount for initiating insolvency under the IBC is ₹1 crore for corporate debtors (as per the 2020 amendment).
Q5. Who is eligible for insolvency?
Any corporate debtor (company or LLP) or individual/partnership firm defaulting on a debt of ₹1 crore or more (for corporates) or ₹1 lakh (for individuals) can face insolvency proceedings. Creditors, including financial and operational creditors, or the debtor itself can initiate the process.
