A contract of indemnity under Indian Contract Act, 1872 is an agreement where one person promises to cover another person's losses, damages, or liabilities caused by certain actions. Think of it like a promise to "have your back" if something goes wrong due to someone’s actions. However, not every agreement that involves paying money or covering losses is an indemnity contract. Let’s break down what does not count as a contract of indemnity, with easy-to-understand explanations and examples.
Elevate your career with a 4-month Certification in Contract Drafting & Negotiation, focusing on AI tools. Gain expertise in drafting contracts across sectors, handling negotiations, and mastering contract life cycle management.
What Makes a Contract of Indemnity?
Before diving into what isn’t an indemnity contract, let’s clarify what is. As per Section 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
A contract of indemnity is when one party promises to protect another from losses caused by the actions of the person making the promise, or by someone else.
Here are the key points
Two Parties: There’s an indemnifier (the one who promises to pay for losses) and an indemnity holder (the one protected from losses).
Type of Loss: The loss must come from actions of people (like mistakes or decisions), not things like natural disasters.
Direct Responsibility: The indemnifier is directly responsible for covering the loss, and it doesn’t depend on someone else failing to do something.
No Debt Needed: Unlike some other contracts, there doesn’t need to be a loan or debt involved.
Also, understand the difference between contract of indemnity and contract of guarantee.
Contracts That Are Not Contracts of Indemnity
Some contracts involve paying money or covering losses but they don’t fit the definition of indemnity. Here are the main ones
1. Contract of Guarantee
A contract of guarantee (covered under Section 126 of the Indian Contract Act) is different from indemnity. In terms of guarantee, a party (called the guarantor) promises to step in and pay or fulfill an obligation if the other party (the principal debtor) fails to do so. It’s like saying, “I’ll cover the payment if my friend doesn’t pay their loan.” This is not about covering a loss but ensuring someone else’s debt or duty is handled.
Example: Imagine you co-sign a loan for your cousin. If your cousin doesn’t repay the bank, you (the guarantor) have to pay. This is a guarantee, not an indemnity, because you’re not covering a loss but stepping in for someone else’s failure.
2. Breach of Contract
When someone breaks a contract (like not delivering goods they promised), the other party might get money as compensation, called damages. This isn’t an indemnity contract. A breach of contract is about fixing the harm caused by not following through on a deal, not about promising to cover future risks or losses.
Example: If a company promises to deliver 100 chairs but only delivers 50, you might sue for the cost of the missing chairs. This is compensation for their failure, not an indemnity agreement to protect you from risks.
3. Tort Claims
A tort is a legal term for a civil wrong, like causing an accident or damaging someone’s property. If someone agrees to pay for harm caused by a tort (e.g., paying for damage from a car crash), this isn’t an indemnity contract. Indemnity is about a specific promise to cover losses from certain events, while tort claims are about fixing harm caused by wrongful actions, not a pre-agreed promise.
Example: If someone crashes into your car and agrees to pay for repairs, that’s a tort claim (fixing a wrong), not an indemnity contract, because there was no prior agreement to cover such losses.
4. Wagering Contracts
A wagering contract is like a bet, where money is paid based on the outcome of an uncertain event such as a sports game or a race. These are not indemnity contracts because they’re about winning or losing a bet, not protecting someone from a loss caused by actions.
Example: If you and a friend bet on who will win a football match, one of you pays the other based on the result. This is a wager, not indemnity, because it’s about the game’s outcome, not covering a loss.
Read to learn more about Drafting Commercial Contracts
Why These Contracts Are Different
To summarize, contracts like guarantees, breaches of contract, tort claims, and wagering agreements aren’t indemnity contracts because:
They involve different purposes (e.g., ensuring a debt is paid vs. covering a loss).
They may have more parties (like a guarantor, debtor, and creditor in a guarantee).
The type of loss or payment isn’t tied to a promise to protect against specific risks caused by actions.
For example:
In terms of guarantee, the focus is on someone else’s failure to pay or perform.
In a breach of contract, it’s about fixing a broken promise, not preventing a loss.
In torts, it’s about fixing harm and not a pre-planned agreement to cover risks.
In wagering, it’s about chance, not protecting against loss.
Summary
Understanding what isn’t a contract of indemnity helps clarify what indemnity actually is. Contracts like guarantees, breaches of contract, tort claims, and wagering agreements might involve money changing hands, but they don’t match the specific promise to cover losses caused by actions, as defined in the Indian Contract Act. By knowing these differences, you can better navigate legal agreements in business or personal matters!
Related Posts
What is Not a Contract of Indemnity: FAQs
Q1. What is a contract of indemnity?
It’s an agreement where one person (the indemnifier) promises to pay for losses or damages that another person (the indemnitee) suffers because of actions by the indemnifier, the indemnitee, or someone else.
Q2. How does the Indian Contract Act define it?
Section 124 says it’s a contract where one party agrees to cover losses caused by their own actions or someone else’s actions.
Q3. Are insurance contracts a type of indemnity?
Yes! Insurance is a classic example of indemnity. For instance, if you have car insurance, the insurer promises to cover repair costs if your car is damaged in an accident.
Q4. How is a contract of indemnity different from a contract of guarantee?
In indemnity, one person directly promises to cover another’s losses. In a guarantee, a third person promises to pay or fulfill an obligation if the main person (debtor) fails to do so. Indemnity is about loss; guarantee is about ensuring someone else’s duty is met.
