Writing a legal research paper is a capstone skill for law students, bringing together your research, analysis, and writing abilities. This article provides a step-by-step guide from planning to final editing on how to write a legal research paper. Following these steps will help ensure your paper is clear, well-argued, and properly cited which reflects the high standards of legal writing.
Unlock legal research, compliance, and case management expertise with our Advanced Training Program in Paralegal Studies & Legal Documentation. Self-paced, expert-led, and filled with real-world case studies to prepare you for success in law firms and corporate legal teams.
Steps to Write a Legal Research Paper
Following are some steps to follow on how to write a legal research paper:
Step 1: Planning and Choosing a Topic
Before writing, ensure you have a focused topic (as discussed in Chapter 2). Once your topic or research question is set, spend time planning.
Develop a research plan: break down the questions you need to answer and identify sources for each. For example, if your paper is on “privacy rights in workplace monitoring,” plan to research employment law statutes, key privacy cases, possibly regulations or guidelines, and some comparative or policy perspectives.
Jot down an outline of issues to cover. Identify any hypothesis or thesis you intend to argue. At this stage, gather your sources and read them thoroughly.
Good writing is built on a strong understanding of the material. Take detailed notes, organize key points by subtopic and keep track of citations for each piece of information (this will save you from hunting for them later).
Step 2: Outlining the Structure
A clear structure is the backbone of a good paper. Generally, a legal research paper (or law review article) will include: Introduction, Background (or Literature Review), Analysis/Discussion, and Conclusion plus proper citations throughout. Start by outlining these main parts and then break the analysis into subheadings.
Step 3: Writing the Introduction
The introduction is crucial because it sets the stage. It should clearly state your thesis or research question, explain the paper’s purpose, and sometimes provide a roadmap of what follows. In the introduction, give a quick context: why is this topic important or timely?
For example: “Data privacy in the workplace is a growing concern as employers adopt surveillance technologies. This paper examines the legal limits on employee monitoring and argues that current laws insufficiently protect employee privacy.” Here, the second sentence is the thesis.
After the thesis, some writers include a brief summary of the paper’s structure (roadmap), e.g., “Part I describes current workplace privacy laws. Part II analyzes recent court decisions on employee monitoring. Part III proposes legislative changes to better safeguard privacy.” This roadmap prepares the reader. Keep the introduction concise, its job is to introduce the problem and your plan to tackle it.
Get to Know What Makes Paralegals and Lawyers Different?
Step 4: Background/Literature Review
Often, before diving into analysis, you need to cover background information or review existing literature. This section (or sections) might include: a history of the law, an overview of the statutory/regulatory framework, or a summary of scholarly debates on the topic.
For example, if writing on a constitutional issue, you might have a section on the historical development of that constitutional doctrine. If empirical data or international law comparisons are part of your paper, you may explain methodology or foreign legal context here.
The background section should set out the foundational knowledge the reader needs to understand your analysis.
Ensure this section is well-cited – you are often recounting established facts or laws, so sources (cases, statutes, academic commentary) must be cited. Be careful to keep this section neutral and expository so you can save your critiques or arguments for the analysis section. The background is like laying out the pieces of the puzzle.
Step 5: Analysis/Discussion
This is the core of your paper where you engage with the issue, apply law to facts, argue different viewpoints, and support your thesis. It’s often the longest part. Here are some tips for the analysis section:
Organize by Sub-Issues: Each paragraph or group of paragraphs should cover a logical sub-issue or argument. Use the IRAC/CRAC structure (Issue, Rule, Application/Analysis, Conclusion) within each segment if applicable, especially in memos or case analyses. For instance, if analyzing constitutionality, you might take each prong of a legal test as a subheading and analyze how the issue meets or fails that prong.
Use Headings and Transitions: Headings (as simple as “A. Legal Standard for X” or descriptive ones like “Privacy Expectations in the Digital Workplace”) help readers follow along. They also keep your writing focused on that sub-topic. Transition sentences at the start or end of paragraphs help connect ideas (“Having discussed the statutory framework, the analysis now turns to how courts have interpreted these statutes in practice.”).
Present Arguments and Counterarguments: If your paper is argumentative (making a case for something), strengthen it by acknowledging counterarguments. You might structure it such that you explain the opposing view, then refute it with reasoning and sources. This shows you’ve critically engaged with the topic, not just one-sidedly advocated.
Integrate Sources Effectively: As you make points, cite relevant authority. If you assert, “However, courts have been reluctant to recognize a broad privacy right,” follow with a footnote citing cases or articles illustrating that. Use quotations sparingly for key language, but mostly paraphrase and analyze. Always explain the significance of a cited case or source in your own words; don’t assume the reader will draw the inference. For example, after citing a case, explain how it supports or contrasts with your argument.
Stay on Track with Your Thesis: Everything in your analysis should tie back to answering your research question or supporting your thesis. It’s easy to get lost in interesting tangents; discipline yourself to ask, “Does this help resolve my main issue?” If not, consider cutting or trimming it.
Use examples or hypotheticals if helpful: Sometimes illustrating a complex legal point with a brief hypothetical scenario or a real-world example can clarify it. Just make sure that it is relevant and not too lengthy.
Step 6: Conclusion
The conclusion should not introduce new analysis or evidence. It should concisely summarize your findings or argument and provide a closing insight. In a scholarly paper, the conclusion might also suggest areas for future research or any unresolved questions. For a position paper, the conclusion may reiterate why your proposal or argument makes sense given everything discussed. Make sure the conclusion gives the reader a sense of completion – answer the question you posed at the start.
Step 7: Editing and Proofreading
Once you have a full draft, revisit it with fresh eyes. Editing is where good papers become great. Key things to check:
Logical Flow: Does the sequence of sections and paragraphs make sense? Adjust ordering if needed for better flow. Ensure transitions are smooth.
Clarity and Concision: Legal writing values clarity and conciseness. Remove redundant phrases, simplify convoluted sentences, and define or remove jargon. Ensure each paragraph has a clear topic sentence and sticks to it. Break up overly long paragraphs for readability.
Strength of Argument: Check if you have fully supported your assertions. If any claim in your paper sounds weak or unsubstantiated, either bolster it with more evidence/authority or qualify it. Ensure you didn’t overlook addressing a major counterargument.
Citation Check: Verify every footnote. Ensure that every claim that needs a citation has one (e.g., factual statements, quotations, specific legal propositions). Check that footnote formats are consistent (e.g., ibid, supra usage correct per the style you use) and that sources are accurately referenced (correct page numbers, etc.). It’s helpful to compile your Bibliography/References at this stage (if required separately) and ensure all sources cited in footnotes appear in the bibliography in proper form, and vice versa.
Grammar and Spelling: These matter a lot in legal writing – errors can distract or undermine your ethos. Use your word processor’s spell check but don’t rely solely on it (it won’t catch legal terms or homophones sometimes). Pay attention to common pitfalls like misuse of possessives, typos in case names, etc.
Formatting: Ensure your paper meets the required format guidelines (margins, font, spacing). Typically, law papers might require double-spacing, specific font size, etc. Make sure headings are styled consistently. If using footnotes, ensure they’re in a readable font size and that footnote numbering hasn’t gotten scrambled with edits.
Read it Aloud: This can catch awkward phrasing or missing words. It also helps you gauge the tone – it should sound professional and formal (no colloquial language unless in a quote), yet clear.
Step 8: Citing and Referencing Properly
Throughout writing, and especially in editing, keep a keen eye on citations. In legal writing, footnotes are usually the norm for citations (Bluebook or other citation styles). If you’re writing a seminar paper or law review-style piece, use footnotes for all references. Every assertion of law needs a citation to authority (case, statute, etc.), and every direct quotation needs a citation with a pinpoint. If you are drawing from an author’s idea, cite them even if not quoting (to avoid plagiarism). As noted earlier, consistency in citation format is key. Students often use citation guides or tools; still, double-check manually as automated tools can error in legal citation nuances.
Also learn about Footnotes in legal research.
Summary
Writing a legal research paper is iterative and at times challenging, but it is also an opportunity to dive deeply into a legal issue and contribute your analysis. By systematically planning, structuring your work, and paying attention to detail in writing and citation, you can produce a paper that is not only academically successful but also something you’re proud of. Remember that legal writing is persuasive at its core even if you’re not writing a brief, you are persuading the reader of your thesis through logical argument and evidence. So frame everything to support that objective. With diligent research and careful writing, you’ll write a piece that showcases your legal acumen and writing skills. By following these steps, law students can approach it as a manageable process, turning a potentially daunting task into a series of achievable stages, ultimately yielding a polished and insightful piece of legal writing.
Related Posts:
How to Write Legal Research: FAQs
Q1. How do I write a strong thesis?
Make it specific and arguable (e.g., “Privacy laws need reform to address digital searches”). Ensure it guides your paper.
Q2. How should I organize the paper?
Use IRAC (Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion): state the issue, cite laws, analyze cases, and conclude. Add clear headings.
Q3. How do I cite correctly?
Follow Bluebook (e.g., Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973)). Use citation tools to ensure accuracy.
Q4. What mistakes should I avoid?
Avoid broad topics, ignoring counterarguments, weak sources, plagiarism, and shallow analysis.
